Universal groups, global groups, domain local groups

AD Group types: universal groups, global groups, domain local groups

Groups 

Distribution Groups — Used for email. Useful for programs such as MS Exchange.
Security Groups – Used to secure file/folders, printers, etc.

Local – Stored on the local SAM (Local Computers)
Domain Local – Stored on Domain Controllers.
Global Groups – Gives you a greater group scope.
Universal – Gives you an even broader group scope.

Group Scopes

Group scope normally describes the type of users that should be clubbed together in a way that is easy for their administration. Therefore, groups play an important part in domain. One group can be a member of other group(s), which is known as Group nesting. One or more groups can be members of any group in the entire domain(s) within a forest.

  • Domain Local Group: Use this scope to grant permissions to domain resources that are located in the same domain in which the domain local group was created. Domain local groups can exist in all mixed, native, and interim functional level of domains and forests. Domain local group memberships are not limited as users can add members as user accounts and universal and global groups from any domain. Nesting cannot be done in a domain local group. A domain local group will not be a member of another Domain Local or any other groups in the same domain.
  • Global Group: Users with similar functions can be grouped under global scope and can be given permission to access a resource (like a printer or shared folder and files) available in local or another domain in the same forest. Simply put, global groups can be use to grant permissions to gain access to resources that are located in any domain but in a single forest as their memberships are limited. User accounts and global groups can be added only from the domain in which the global group is created. Nesting is possible in Global groups within other groups as users can add a global group into another global group from any domain. They can be members of a Domain Local group to provide permission to domain specific resources (like printers and published folder). Global groups exist in all mixed, native, and interim functional level of domains and forests.
  • Universal Group Scope: these groups are precisely used for email distribution and can be granted access to resources in all trusted domain as these groups can only be used as a security principal (security group type) in a windows 2000 native or windows server 2003 domain functional level domain. Universal group memberships are not limited like global groups. All domain user accounts and groups can be a member of a universal group. Universal groups can be nested under a global or Domain Local group in any domain. 

Universal Group: can contain users and groups (global and universal) from any domain in the forest.  Universal groups do not care about trust.  Universal groups can be a member of domain local groups or other universal groups but NOT global groups.

Global Group: can contain users, computers and groups from same domain but NOT universal groups.  Can be a member of global groups of the same domain, domain local groups or universal groups of any domain in the forest or trusted domains.

Domain Local Group:  Can contain users, computers, global groups and universal groups from any domain in the forest and any trusted domain, and domain local groups from the same domain.  Can be a member of any domain local group in the same domain.

The short answer is that domain local groups are the only groups that can have members from outside the forest. And use global groups if you have trust, universal groups if you don’t care about trust.

When do we need to use local, global and universal group permission?

Use global security groups to group user (or computer) accounts with similar characteristics, for example members of Sales department.

Use domain local security groups to define access to resources (share, NTFS, printer),
for example you would create domain local group “DL ColorPrinter Print” and assign print permission to this group. Then you would put global security group Sales in “DL ColorPrinter Print” group to enable printing for sales department. If marketing department wants to use the same printer you have to create global group Marketing and put this group in “DL ColorPrinter Print” group. This strategy is called A-G-DL-P. Put accounts in global groups, global groups in domain local groups and assign permissions to domain local groups and you will assign permission only once. Everything else happens in Active Directory Users and Computers when you modify groups memberships.

Universal groups should only be used in multiple domain forest. Universal groups are used to nest global groups. Group strategy is then called A-G-U-DL-P.

In shot below are the details

Global Groups:
Use these to group users with similar needs within the organisation, sales people, finance people, manager’s etc

Domain Local Groups:
Use these to specify access to resources e.g. database users, Colour Printer Users.

Universal Groups
Use only in mulitiple domains to give forest wide privileges.

One Comment

  1. Hello Sandesh,

    Thank you for taking the time to share for everyone the differences between the various groups in Active Direcotry. I know this is a confusing topic for many admins, so this is certainly very helpful.

    One related issue to the security groups in Active Directory, is trying to find out where all a group is granted any kind of permissions in the Active Directory, and that is something we have been trying to find out too.

    One of the best discussions I found on this challenge that many of us face was – How to find out where a domain security group has permissions in our Active Directory?

    I thought I would share with you, so it can be helpful to you too. Of course, if you have some thoughts on that you can also share as it would be helpful to everyone.

    Also, you are an Enterprise Admin, and I aim to reach there someday, so congratulations to you for your success. It is very important position with lot of trust and responsibility I am sure.

    Thanks you.
    Chaitanya

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *